The Pentagon is expected to make plans for “The golden dome“For Trump this week. In the most famous sense, the golden dome is a missile defense system that will shoot nuclear weapons, missiles and drones that threaten the United States from the sky. A scientific study published earlier this month, separating the scientific impossibility of the scheme.
America has tried to build a missile defense system since Ronald Reagan was president. Reagan wanted to put satellite in space that would use the laser to detonate Soviet nuclear weapons from the sky. We didn’t have been more than pedestrians. Maybe it will not work either. But defense contractors earned a lot of money.
“When engineers were subjected to extensive political pressure to spread a system, the United States has repeatedly began costly programs that have proven that they were unable to deal with the main technical challenges and were eventually abandoned with the appearance of their shortcomings.” New study From the American Physical Society Committee on Public Affairs.
Under Trump, we will do it again.
Trump signed an executive order on January 27 and called on the Pentagon to Reach a plan For an “iron dome for America”, which was taken by the president and others to invite a “golden dome”. According to EO, Trump wants a plan that will preserve the homeland in safe from “ballistic, advanced, advanced missiles, and other air attacks from peers, nearby leadership, and rogue opponents.”
The dream of the golden dome is simple: shooting missiles from the sky before they can cause any harm. “It is important that you simply not think about the golden dome as the next repetition of the ground defense system or the missile defense system only because it is a wider task than that,” said Jonathan Money, CEO of Balawawo, a defense company that works on the neighboring golden technology, for Gizmodo.
The money maker was clear about the challenges of building the golden dome. He said: “Everyone looks at this as a copy to repeat the Iron Dome in Israel, but we have to appreciate that Israel is the size of New Jersey.”
The Iron Iron dome, Israel, has done a great job to shoot down Rots Hamas and Iranian missiles. It also covers a small area and dropped the projectiles that do not move at the speed of the nuclear weapon or the Russian ballistic Kinzhal weapon. The degree of the golden dome is that it will keep the whole continent in safety. This is a huge amount of land that must be covered and the system will need to determine, track and destroy nuclear weapons, drones and other things that move at high speed.
This is like an attempt to shoot a bullet from the sky with a bullet. Swimming defense study, Posted on March 3Detailing some challenges facing a potential system similar to the golden dome.
Trump’s CEO is mysterious and covers many potential threats. “We are focusing on the primary question about whether the current and proposed systems aimed at defending the United States against a nuclear -weapon ballistic missile (transit ballistic missile) are now effective, or in the near future it can be effective in preventing death and destruction that results in a successful attack by North Korea on the United States using this ICBMS.”
Nuke stopping is the primary promise of the missile system. And if one of these systems is not able to stop Nuke, what is the benefit?
The study is not positive. “This is the most comprehensive and independent scientific study for decades on the feasibility of the national missile defense. Its results may lead to the shock of Americans who have not paid much attention to these programs,” Joseph Sirinsion told Gimzodo.
CIRINCIONE is the retired president of the Plowshares Fund and a former Congress. He investigated the missile defense systems and nuclear weapons of the Armed Services Committee in the House of Representatives. He said: “We have no chance to stop a missile attack that won the United States despite four decades of attempt and more than $ 400 billion spent. This is the mother of all scandals.”
The study looked at some different ways to expel North Korea from the sky. ICBM’s launch contains three phases: the reinforcement phase that lasts only a few minutes, the Midcourse phase that lasts for about 20 minutes, and the peripheral stage of less than one minute.
During the reinforcement phase, NUKE builds speed and entering the air. The study said: “The objection of the augmented phase of ICBMS launched from a small country like North Korea is a challenge.”
You must get weapons close to the missile, and in the case of North Korea, this requires construction near China and then shooting it on Chinese soil. Any defensive system will only have a few moments to respond to Nuke because the reinforcement stage lasts only a few minutes.
In order for the counter -procedure that ICBM under these time restrictions means that it will need to be built closely, and perhaps somewhere in the Pacific Ocean. We will need many of them. China will not be satisfied with an episode of missile defense systems near its borders, regardless of how America tries to sell them.
But what about space systems? It is land competitors with less power. “The Scientific Review Committee has found that it would take a thousand orbits to counter one North Korean ballistic missile. Until then,” the system will be expensive and exposed to anti -tourism attacks. “About 3,600 objections are accurate.
So we are talking about the planet’s ringing with thousands of armed satellites. And remember that this is only to deal with Nuke one launched by North Korea. Imagine an increase in a defensive shield similar to protection from all nuclear weapons in Russia and will start seeing the size of the problem.
Well, what about the laser? Reagan’s original plan was laser. Certainly technology has advanced since the 1980s. The study said: “There is a large -scale agreement that laser weapons that can disable ICBMS during the reinforcement period, whether based on planes, drones, or space platforms, will not be technically possible during the time horizon for 15 years of this study.”
This hints to one of the missile defense problems: it takes a long time to build and your enemies are not numbers during this happening. While America is working on the golden dome, Russia, North Korea and China, China will build new and different types of weapons aimed at circumventing them. We may be able to build a laser who is able to launch nuclear weapons from heaven for two decades, but by that time America may have things to deal with the laser.
Well, so building systems to drop Nuke in the reinforcement phase is a logistical and geopolitical nightmare. What about during the middle of the session? There is more time to do something, between 20 and 30 minutes. Most of the currently deployed missile defense systems are designed in America Hit the body.
“The absence of air clouds during this stage means that the debris, such as the upper stages consumed, deployment and height control units, separation and debris of non -burning fuel, isolation, and other parts of the enhanced, as well as missile fragments that were deliberately created by crime and light light, said everything he follows.” This makes it difficult for defense to distinguish warheads from other things in ” This threat cloud, “so that the warheads can be targeted.”
In tests, MIDCOORSE interceptors in America only run about half the time. These tests take place under perfect conditions against known threats. The study said: “After carefully reviewing technology and testing for the Midcourse system (Midcourse), the report concludes that its reliable and weakness to counter measures is seriously limited to its effectiveness.”
There is still the peripheral stage, which is less than a second before Nuke strikes its goal. The United States also has systems, such as defending the high height area of the station, designed to expel a missile from the air during this decisive moment.
The truth is that if Nuke is close, you may have already been lost. The study said: “Even effective peripheral defenses can only defend limited areas.” “Moreover, peripheral sensors are subject to pre -effects of nuclear explosions in the atmosphere.”
These are only a few problems discussed by researchers in the 60 -page report. There is a lot. And remember that this only talks about the dropping of North Korea Salvo. Things become more complicated when adding Russia, China or any other American enemies.
As for CIRINCIONE, the report confirmed his long belief that any kind of complex missile defense system is not worth the cost of its construction. “In short, we cannot defend the country against a firm missile attack now or at any time in the foreseeable future,” he said. “While we can intercept short -range missiles like that used in the Middle East or Ukraine, there is no zero opportunity we can intercept long -range missiles that extend to the oceans. We have spent more than $ 400 billion since 1983 on anything. Future expenditures will just throw money on the mice hole.”
The money maker was up. He said: “When the nation can agree on a goal, whether it is a stars war or the golden dome or send someone to the moon, when you have an important unit, many things can occur.”
He also pointed out that the golden dome was a huge opportunity for sabotage defense companies such as Anduril, Naam, Bluehalo. He said that the golden dome was an unprecedented scale. The construction of any system of a proposed cooperation between government and local officials, the police, the Coast Guard, the Federal Investigation Office, and the Ministry of National Security. “There are a lot of ingredients in playing that have an integration arrangement from the next level that must happen.”
In the imagination of Moneymaker, the golden dome will not be just one system but a wide mixture of weapons covering the United States. “Is this one dome? Or is it a series of unified domes that interact with each other?
The money maker explained that the targets of high value such as military bases or large metro areas may get protection first and then woven together in “tissue or tissue of protection”. He said that the project is so great that progress will be gradual. “The good news is that I think we can go quickly as a nation when we need or want it.”
In Washington this week, there is a talk about the creation of a A full new section Only to deal with the development of the golden dome. Bose Allen Hamilton Swarm From drones the size of the refrigerator flying in 20 tropical aircraft 200 miles in the air. This plan aims to identify drones from artificial intelligence to determine the missiles when they arrive and slide in them.
This is just one of the many stadiums received by the Trump administration. according to Defense oneThe Pentagon got more than 360 plannings related to the golden dome. “I completely expect the Trump administration to ignore this serious scientific advice, just as it rejects the scientific truth in the climate crisis, vaccines and the environment,” Sirinsion said. “When there is money that can be earned, the flag is set aside.”
https://gizmodo.com/app/uploads/2025/04/MissileDefense.jpg
Source link