How accurate is the Clint Eastwood movie?

Films based on real people need a balance on a tight rope between adhering to the real story and throwing parts of them in the wind to make things more exciting. Discover the biography of Ruby Williams with a monkey character “Best Man” The strange movie became the first large box office bomb. On the other hand, elegant exaggeration can also take advantage of a movie – for example, 1984 “Amadeus” is the best musical biography of all ages and also inaccurate with joy.

advertisement

The 2014 War Eastwood war film “American snipers” It was a great success at the box office, and that the nature of the film “based on a true story” means that it deals with the usual CV challenges. The film tells the story of Chris Kyle (played by Bradley Cooper) – a famous naval sniper with more than 160 confirmed killings – and is based on his 2012 memoirs of the same name. He was nominated for six Academy Awards (Oscars for the best achievement in proper liberation) and received praise from the veterans for photographing the war in Iraq. On the other hand, its unusual praise for Kyle, and a questionable photography of “brutal” enemies, and “America is always right” has attracted criticism.

advertisement

While “American Sniper” depicts some of the events that have already happened, the film also comes with a list of washing of inaccuracy and biographical impulses – and unless the viewer has a deep knowledge of the personal Kyle and the Iraq War, many of which can be more difficult than discovering the angry stent that could be the infant who could carry. Let’s take a look at the accuracy of the American “snipers”.

A movie adaptation of notes can be difficult, and on certain basic occasions, “American Snper” chooses to distort the story of Chris Kyle. In fact, the first scene of the movie Kyle is shown in a difficult situation when he sees a woman who receives a tank control bomb to a boy and sends him towards the Marine Corps. This decoration: a similar scene that appears in the book, but with a woman only and explodes much strength. There is also a prominent scene, which is a full manufacturing: the accident in which the Kyle team takes a temporary shelter in a civilian family home, only to end their fighting when snipers discover the cache of the weapons that reveal them from the rebels.

advertisement

Another important change in Kyle’s story in the movie is his motive to become a military man. The filming of the film for Kyle joins the navy after seeing footage of the 1998 American embassy bombings that have nothing to do with reality – the real Kyle that was recruited shortly before it happened and always wanted to do so. Other main changes include a colleague of Kyle Seal Ryan “Biggles” (Jake McDorman), who dies in Iraq in the movie. In fact, he was blind and died in 2009 after undergoing surgery to rebuild the face in Arizona. Mill Kyle was to use satellite phones in the middle of the stage to speak with his wife, Taya (Sienna Miller), largely exaggerated for the dramatic influence, and the film differs from the book when it comes to photographing the husband’s relationship and interactions.

advertisement

Jean -Jack Arnoud’s 2001 movie “The Enemy in The Gates” is filming a fictional duel between Jude Law as the famous Soviet snipers wwii Vasily Zaitsev and Ed Harris as the alleged German sniping legend (but very historically). “American snipers” chooses a similar approach by writing Kyle against a scary Syrian sniper known only as Mustafa (Sami Shik) – the unknown ghost of death, whose only distinctive features are in its deadly accuracy and background as an enormous Olympic Olympics. The frequent presence in the film represents a serious threat, to the extent that he is the person who kills Biggles. It is appropriate to prepare Sniper Duel, the film also places it at the recipient of the famous Kyle divorce with an area of ​​2,100 yards.

advertisement

Mustafa, as it appears in the movie, was not present. While a sniper with this name with a rumor history as an Olympic gets a short male in the book, Kyle specifically wrote that he had no interaction with the man. On the contrary, he mentioned that Mustafa might be killed by another American sniper. As such, the goal of the famous KYLE shot-instead, was not the Througal team that runs a hand grenade.

However, at least Mustafa was already mentioned in the notes. The same thing can be said to the Butcher (Mido Hamada), a one brutal villain with zero recovery characteristics that act as a main target of marine seals … and do not appear in the book at all. Al -Jazzar may require or not inspire a loose inspiration from a real Shiite Muslim militia leader known as Abu Deira (who has no connection to Kyl), but frankly, it is a mono -dimensional basin, that is, related to a real person doubtful at best.

advertisement

One of the very prominent events that the film is very sparkling is the death of Chris Kyle. At the end of the movie, Kyle left the army behind it, and after some difficult times, on his way to re -discover the pleasures of civil life. Then he tells his wife that he is heading to meet an ancient warrior in the shooting scope – and the film is frankly that the old warriors killed him on the same day before he cut archive clips for Kyle and his funeral.

advertisement

This is what happened in real life as well, although the film leaves a large part of the sad story. Just like a fictional version, the real Kyle also devoted a lot of energy to help other old warriors, often use fire – an activity they were all familiar with – as a way to reach them. In this capacity, Kyle and his veteran teammate Chad Littlefield agreed to interview Marine Edi Ray Roth in Rough Creek Lodge and Resort Gun Range in Texas on February 2, 2013. Ruth, who had a history of mental health and was under influence at that time, shot both men.

Interestingly, “American Snper” is not ashamed of the changes he made on the original story. On the contrary, screenwriter Jason Hall was completely open about changing events from those explained in the book, as he also made it clear his reasons for doing this. In the 2015 interview with New York Daily NewsHe explained that although Kyle’s death was in several versions of the scenario, she eventually did not get more attention because his family specifically asked for tact – and Hall ended up with approval:

advertisement

“I did not want to be the thing that was suspended on (his children) heading for the rest of their lives, as the movie that showed that their father was shooting.”

This was not the only way Kyle’s sudden death also affected the movie. In fact, tell Hall Military.com In 2014, more than half of his text passed a great reform after Kyle was killed and Taya Kyle became more involved in the creative process, providing an insightful look that enables Hall to portray Kyle as a less dimension than he is in the book:

(The scenario) changed about 60 percent. The family participated much more and was able to obtain the sounds correctly and I was able to understand who Chris was before the war and how this man was with this big heart, and this uncommon tenderness was able to pull this girl from the dark when she wandered in the dark.

advertisement

Regardless of all the changes made on the film, the book on which it depends does not contain a busy record as the most reliable Bible there. Kyle’s notes were the subject of some controversy over the years. One of her stories is characterized by Kyle, which expels a famous person-who later confirmed that he was a professional wrestler Jesse Ventura-and ended up causing a legal problem, as Ventura filed a law against Kyle in a case eventually settled for an unannounced group in 2017. This story was not in new editions of the book since 2014, and it is fully understood.

advertisement

Another case appeared in 2016, when objection Publishing the investigation of Kyle military record. In the book, Kyle states that he was decorated with two silver stars and five bronze stars, but Internet information indicated that these numbers were decorated and that his actual record was a silver star and three bronze stars. This aspect ended from the story of Kyle to very complicated. Mention of the 2009 naval separation model already silver stars and six The bronze … but after the 2016 review, the navy reviewed the counting of one silver star and four stars of bronze for Fallor.

In general, there is little denial that Chris Kyle was a complex person and a talented sniper, that the performance of the film in general and the performance of Bradley Cooper in particular are doing an excellent job in photographing the type of military life that was described in the famous navy in his autobiography. However, if you prefer a historic war drama historically, not to mention those that somewhat criticize its subject, it is good to remember that the “American sniper” draws its image with a fairly broad stroke and puts its subject on the basis of the statue.

advertisement