Best Mattress for Combination Sleeping of 2024

CNET editors select the products and services we write about based on editorial merit. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.

When we test mattresses, we have a well-established process that evaluates key factors, including firmness, feel and performance. We test the strength of the edge of the bed by sitting and lying on the edge. We test motion transfer by rolling onto the mattress with a cup of water at the edge. These are things we do for all the beds we test. The best mattresses for mixed sleepers go through a unique testing process. We go deeper into the construction of the bed, paying attention to every layer that contributes to the cooling process.

1. Firmness: We go over every mattress and use our experience testing over 200 different beds to determine how firm a mattress is. We analyze how soft or firm the bed is compared to other mattresses. It is important to wait until the mattress has fully expanded after initially taking it out of the box to get a true firmness perspective.

2. feel: This is where we deal with family. We touch the mattress, feel it and observe what the material does. Is it light and bouncy like latex foam, or is it slow and dense like memory foam?

3. durability: We don’t lie on our mattress every day for years, so it’s hard to know exactly how long each bed will last. We can get an idea of ​​how well a bed will hold up by looking at its construction. Steel coil beds are usually more durable and stronger than all-foam mattresses.

4. Body type: We use construction and sense to determine how well a bed is suitable for a heavy person. Steel coil hybrid mattresses are usually more supportive and last longer, which is a plus for heavier individuals looking for a higher-quality bed.

5. Sleeping position: We get physical, tossing and turning around the mattresses and testing every sleeping position: side, back, stomach, and combination.

6. Motion isolation: With one or two people on the mattress, we jump and bounce to see how much movement can be detected throughout the bed. We also use the method of placing a cup of water on the edge of the bed and jumping around to see how much it moves.

7. Edge support: We analyze the mattress materials and actually lie on each edge of the mattress to see how well it makes us feel sturdy and like we won’t fall off the edge.

8. Temperature: We use heated sheets to test and determine how cool the bed is. We also examine their materials and construction to see if the brand has added anything to make them cooler.

9. jade: Some mattresses can give off an interesting smell. We use our trusty noses to test this feature.

Read more about How we test mattresses.